Meeting Votes

February 18, 2020 - February 21, 2020

Logistics Agenda Presentations Attendance Votes Notes
Registered: 28
OOE: 28
IMOVE: 24
Votes needed for individual vote quorum:



  1. Vote Topic: #153: Possible error/gap in the specification of MPI_NEIGHBOR_ALLTOALL (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  2. Vote Topic: #122: Intro nonblocking, no serialization and no deadlocks - changelog (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    15 1 8 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  3. Vote Topic: #122: Intro nonblocking, no serialization and no deadlocks - can be used to avoid (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  4. Vote Topic: #79: Callback-driven event interface for MPI_T - remove extent (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  5. Vote Topic: #79: Callback-driven event interface for MPI_T - timestamp as count (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  6. Vote Topic: #147: Deprecate MPI_Info_get and MPI_Info_get_valuelen (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  7. Begin New Voting Day


  8. Vote Topic: #103: Changes to the MPI Sessions proposal for 1st vote (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  9. Vote Topic: #137: Changes to the BigCount proposal for reading (no-no)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    24 0 0 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  10. Vote Topic: #158: Formal approval of Ticket 0 Pythonization Changes (errata)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    24 0 0 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  11. Vote Topic: #153: Possible error/gap in the specification of MPI_NEIGHBOR_ALLTOALL (errata)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    24 0 0 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  12. Vote Topic: #103: MPI Sessions (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 3 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  13. Vote Topic: #143: Creating an MPI_INFO_ENV object before MPI_INIT. (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  14. Vote Topic: #132: Hardware split, guided mode. (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  15. Vote Topic: #156: Hardware split, unguided mode. (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    20 2 2 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  16. Vote Topic: #136: Partitioned Point-to-Point Communication (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    18 2 4 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  17. Vote Topic: #122: Intro nonblocking, no serialization and no deadlocks (1st)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    24 0 0 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  18. Vote Topic: #125: Add nonblocking and persistent versions of sendrecv (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    17 2 5 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  19. Vote Topic: #121: Clarify alignment of memory provided to applications (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    24 0 0 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  20. Vote Topic: #79: Callback-driven event interface for MPI_T (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    24 0 0 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  21. Vote Topic: #146: Fix Security Issue with MPI_Info_get by Introducing New Replacement Function MPI_Info_get_string (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 0 1 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK
  22. Vote Topic: #147: Deprecate MPI_Info_get and MPI_Info_get_valuelen (2nd)
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    23 1 0 0
    ATOS Argonne Berkeley CEA Cisco Edinburgh Fujitsu HLRS HPE IBM INRIA Intel Livermore Los Alamos Mellanox NVIDIA OSU Oak Ridge Paratools Sandia TU Munich UAB UTC UTK