Meeting Votes

April 6 - 8, 2009

Logistics Agenda Presentations Attendance Votes Notes


Individual organization's votes are show as colored blocks as follows:
Yes No Abstain Miss


  1. Vote Topic: #1: Fortran MPI_*_ERRHANDLER callback functions are varargs (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    20 1 1 1

  2. Vote Topic: #3: Repeating a Neighbor in a Graph Communicator Ambiguity with MPI_GRAPH_NEIGHBOR[_COUNT] (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 0 2

  3. Vote Topic: #4: Remove MPI-2.1 A.1.1 p494:31-32 table (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 0 2

  4. Vote Topic: #8: Text Updates to Language Bindings Chapter (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 0 2

  5. Vote Topic: #30: Clarification to intercomm MPI_Barrier (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  6. Vote Topic: #40: MPI-2.1 Errata MPI::F_DOUBLE_COMPLEX (page 495 line 11) (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  7. Vote Topic: #43: MPI_REPLACE in MPI_Accumulate (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 1 1

  8. Vote Topic: #44: Non blocking versus non-blocking versus nonblocking (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    20 0 0 3

  9. Vote Topic: #53: Explicitly encourage routines for 'good' one-sided memory for all memory types (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  10. Vote Topic: #60: Modernize example on p 279 (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  11. Vote Topic: #61: MPI-2.1 Change-Log: Version number modified to 2.1 (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 1 1

  12. Vote Topic: #63: MPI_CHAR for printable characters - C & C++ consisteny (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  13. Vote Topic: #67: MPI-2.1 Errata: Error in name of participating institution for MPI 2.1 (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  14. Vote Topic: #68: MPI-2.1 errata: Need to add acknowledgment for NSF support for MPI 2.1 (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  15. Vote Topic: #74: Nonnegative vs. non-negative (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  16. Vote Topic: #87: Wording changes to collective chapter for consistency (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 0 2

  17. Vote Topic: #89: Philosophical difference with current classification of barriers (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    13 1 7 2

  18. Vote Topic: #90: Minor grammar corrections for collectives chapter (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  19. Vote Topic: #91: Undefined term in description of Reduce-Scatter (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  20. Vote Topic: #92: Need to fix MPI_EXSCAN advice to users (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  21. Vote Topic: #93: Inconsistent description of arrays in collective operations (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  22. Vote Topic: #97: Small bug in RMA example (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  23. Vote Topic: #101: Version number changed to (2,2) (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  24. Vote Topic: #104: MPI_ARGV_NULL and MPI_ARGVS_NULL missing on p465:13-15. (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  25. Vote Topic: #113: Minor typo in MPI_ALLTOALLV (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  26. Vote Topic: #115: Corrections to point-to-point chapter examples (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  27. Vote Topic: #118: Corrections to collectives chapter: fix examples and remove deprecated functions (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  28. Vote Topic: #120: Typos in Collectives Chapter (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  29. Vote Topic: #123: Fix errors in example in profiling chapter (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    22 0 0 1

  30. Vote Topic: #109: MPI-3: Nonblocking Collective Operations (1st vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 0 2

  31. Vote Topic: #9: Consistency in 'Naming Conventions' Section (2nd vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 0 2

  32. Vote Topic: #16: Error in Example 4.18 (2nd vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 0 2

  33. Vote Topic: #17: Fix text about freeing error classes and codes (2nd vote) ()
    Yes No Abstain Missed Result
    21 0 0 2